The Bottom Line
Pros
- Unforgettable characters
- Memorable use of humor
- Crisp writing that keeps the story moving and the reader engaged
- Excellent depiction of time and place
- Accessible to tween readers
Cons
- Literary device of a hoax (dead Indian princess) seen by some as derogatory
Description
- Title: A Season of Gifts
- Author: Richard Peck
- Length: 176 pages
- Recommended For: Ages 9-13
- Publisher: Dial Books for Young Readers, A Division of the Penguin Young Readers Group
- Publication Date: 2009
- ISBN: 9780803730823
Guide Review - A Season of Gifts by Richard Peck
Bob is the target of the town bullies, his older sister Phyllis is pining for Elvis and trying to fit in with the high school crowd, and little sister Ruth Ann longs for a friend. Even though Mrs. Dowdel keeps to herself and isn’t overly friendly, she manages to give each member of the family the kind of gift they most need. Her anonymous gifts of fresh vegetables sustain their bodies, but she finds ways to instill confidence in them, which allows them to grow in spirit.
Mrs. Dowdel manages to give the town bully his just desserts through an act of seeming kindness, to devise a way to bring new members into the church with a funeral service for the spirit of a long-dead Indian princess, and to teach Ruth Ann secrets of how to survive in the world. We see all this unfold through Bob’s bemused eyes, but we feel his strength growing as well. As Ruth Ann would say, “Hoo boy.”
Jean Hatfield has experience as a children’s librarian, a school librarian, and a head librarian. She has served on the selection committee for major children’s book awards and is presently responsible for the selection of public library materials for youth – children and young adults - for the public library system in the largest city in Kansas, Wichita.



